Oscillating Tool vs Reciprocating Saw - Dab tsi yog qhov txawv?

los ntawm Joost Nusselder | Hloov tshiab ntawm:  Lub peb hlis ntuj 16, 2022
Kuv nyiam tsim cov ntsiab lus pub dawb tag nrho cov lus qhia rau kuv cov nyeem, koj. Kuv tsis lees txais kev them nyiaj pab txhawb nqa, kuv lub tswv yim yog kuv tus kheej, tab sis yog tias koj pom kuv cov lus pom zoo pab tau thiab koj kawg yuav yam uas koj nyiam los ntawm ib qho ntawm kuv qhov txuas, Kuv tuaj yeem khwv tau nyiaj ua haujlwm yam tsis tau them nqi ntxiv rau koj. Xav paub ntau ntxiv
Ob ntawm cov cuab yeej siv feem ntau hauv kev siv tes ua haujlwm thiab kev tsim kho yog oscillating ntau lub hom phiaj cov cuab yeej thiab cov saw saws. Ib qho cuab yeej oscillating yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj plaws rau qhov chaw me me, thiab cov saw reciprocating rau kev ua haujlwm demolition.
Oscillating-Tool-vs-Reciprocating-Saw
Txhua tus ntawm lawv muaj qhov cuam tshuam rau qhov sib txawv hauv kev txiav & demolition. Yog li ntawd, nws tseem ceeb heev kom paub qhov tshwm sim ntawm oscillating cuab tam vs reciprocating saw nyob rau hauv txawv kev tsim kho thiab txiav scenarios. Thiab hauv tsab xov xwm no, peb yuav tshawb txog qhov ntawd.

Dab tsi yog Oscillating Tool?

Lub sij hawm oscillating stands rau viav vias rov qab & tawm mus rau hauv lub suab nrov. Yog li, nyob rau hauv dav dav, oscillating stands rau viav vias ntawm ib sab mus rau lwm yam. Qhov no yog raws nraim li cov cuab yeej Oscillating ua. Cov cuab yeej oscillating yog ntau lub hom phiaj professional-qib siv cuab yeej uas siv oscillating motion txiav los ntawm cov khoom & cov ntaub ntawv. Tab sis qhov ntawd tsis yog txhua yam, raws li tau hais tseg, cov cuab yeej oscillating yog suav tias yog cov cuab yeej siv ntau lub hom phiaj, lub ntsiab lus nws tsis yog siv rau kev txiav, tab sis kuj sanding, polishing, sib tsoo, sawing, thiab ntau yam khoom siv tes ua haujlwm. Cov cuab yeej oscillating yog me me thiab tuaj nrog cov hniav me me nrog cov hniav me me tsis ntse. Muaj ntau ntau hom hniav rau koj xaiv los ntawm, thiab tsis yog txhua tus ntawm lawv muaj cov hniav. Raws li nws yog cov cuab yeej siv ntau lub hom phiaj, hloov hom hniav yuav hloov hom kev ua haujlwm uas koj tuaj yeem ua nrog cov cuab yeej. Rau qhov versatility no, cov cuab yeej oscillating koom nrog yuav luag txhua hom ke & kev tsim kho kev ua haujlwm.

Lub cuab yeej Oscillating ua haujlwm li cas?

Cov txheej txheem ua haujlwm ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating zoo ib yam li lwm yam cuab yeej hluav taws xob uas peb ntsib hauv peb lub neej niaj hnub. Feem ntau muaj ob hom oscillating cuab yeej: corded oscillating cuab tam thiab cordless oscillating cuab tam. Kuj tseem muaj lwm qhov kev hloov pauv ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating, tab sis qhov ntawd yog lub ntsiab lus rau lwm lub sijhawm. Tig lub hwj chim hloov yuav ua rau lub cuab yeej los ua lub neej, thiab koj tuaj yeem pib ua haujlwm nrog nws. Raws li tau hais ua ntej, cov cuab yeej oscillating siv oscillating motion rau kev ua haujlwm. Yog li, thaum koj tig nws, cov hniav yuav pib viav vias rov qab thiab tawm mus. Tam sim no, yog tias koj tab tom npaj txiav nrog koj cov cuab yeej oscillating, tsuas yog nias lub cuab yeej ntawm qhov chaw thiab maj mam ua haujlwm los ntawm qhov chaw ntawm cov khoom koj yuav tau txiav. Txoj kev no kuj tseem siv tau rau kev xuab zeb, polishing, sawing, thiab lwm yam kev siv ntawm cov cuab yeej.

Dab tsi yog Reciprocating Saw?

Reciprocating kuj yog ib feem ntawm plaub hom kev ua haujlwm tseem ceeb. Oscillating kuj yog ib feem ntawm nws. Lo lus reciprocating sawv cev rau kev thawb & rub lub suab nrov. Yog li ntawd, cov saw saws tes yog ib qho cuab yeej muaj zog uas siv cov lus tsa suab sib txuas thiab txiav los ntawm yuav luag txhua yam khoom thiab cov khoom uas tib neeg tuaj hla thaum tsim kho lossis rhuav tshem ua haujlwm. Reciprocating saws raug suav hais tias yog ib qho ntawm cov cuab yeej muaj zog tshaj plaws txiav & sawing. Cov hniav ntawm ib tug reciprocating saw siv txoj kev thawb-rub lossis nce-down los txiav txhua yam koj pov rau nws. Nco ntsoov tias koj siv cov hniav zoo uas muaj peev xwm txiav cov khoom koj yuav ua haujlwm. Yog li ntawd, qhov kev ua tau zoo ntawm ib qho kev sib txuas lus pom zoo nyob ntawm cov hniav. Koj yuav pom ntau hom hniav rau sawing & txiav cov khoom sib txawv. Tsis tas li ntawd xwb, tab sis qhov ntev thiab qhov hnyav ntawm cov hniav kuj tuaj rau hauv kev ua si thaum koj npaj txiav ib yam dab tsi nrog cov hniav reciprocating. Qhov kev pom ntawm ib tug reciprocating saw zoo li rab phom. Nws muaj zog thiab hnyav heev piv rau lwm cov saws uas koj tuaj yeem pom hauv koj lub khw muag khoom kho vajtse. Cov corded reciprocating saws hnyav dua piv rau lawv cov cordless versions.

Yuav Ua Li Cas Reciprocating Saw Ua Haujlwm

Raws li tau hais ua ntej, ib rab riam reciprocating siv thawb & rub lossis nce-down txoj kev txiav los yog sawing los ntawm ib qho khoom. Thiab zoo ib yam li cov cuab yeej hluav taws xob feem ntau ntawm kev ua lag luam, ib qho kev sib txuas lus feem ntau muaj ob hom: ib qho corded thiab ib lub cordless.
Yuav ua li cas ib tug reciprocating saw ua haujlwm
Lub corded reciprocating yuav tsum tau txuas nrog ib lub qhov hluav taws xob thaum lub cordless ib lub roj teeb powered. Nyob ntawm seb hom reciprocating pom koj siv, qhov sib npaug thiab lub zog yuav txawv. Thaum siv lub tshuab hluav taws xob, lub tshuab hluav taws xob sib txuas yuav muaj lub zog rov qab. Yog li ntawd, ua ntej powering li lub saw, koj yuav tsum tau ua ib tug balanced txoj hauj lwm kom lub kickback tsis khob koj li. Niaj hnub no, feem ntau reciprocating saws tuaj nrog lub zog thiab kev hloov ceev. Tab sis yog tias koj ntsib tus qauv qub, ces qhov ntawd yuav tsis yog qhov teeb meem, thiab cov saw yuav muaj zog tag nrho los ntawm qhov pib. Qhov no yuav cuam tshuam sai npaum li cas cov txheej txheem sawing yuav nrawm npaum li cas. Lub zog ntau dua thiab nrawm dua cov saw hlau sib txuas, qhov nyuaj nws yuav tswj tau.

Qhov Sib txawv ntawm Cov Cuab Yeej Oscillating & Cov Pom Zoo

Tam sim no muaj ntau qhov sib txawv uas koj tuaj yeem pom ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating thiab cov saw saws. Cov kev sib txawv no ua rau lawv sawv ntawm ib leeg. Qhov sib txawv tshaj plaws uas koj yuav pom ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating thiab cov saw reciprocating yog -

Cov lus tsa suab ntawm txhua lub cuab yeej

Raws li lawv lub npe qhia, oscillating cov cuab yeej siv oscillation tsab ntawv tsa suab los yog rov qab thiab tawm suab, thaum reciprocating pab kiag li lawm siv laub & rub los yog reciprocating tsab ntawv tsa suab. Txawm hais tias, ntau tus xav tias qhov no yog qhov sib txawv me me, lub hauv paus ntawm txhua lub cuab yeej nyob ntawm qhov teeb meem no. Vim tias vim lawv cov lus tsa suab tshwj xeeb, txoj kev txiav yog txawv kiag li. Qhov no cuam tshuam tsis tau tsuas yog qhov sib npaug tab sis kuj ua haujlwm ntawm cov cuab yeej. Piv txwv li, yog tias koj npaj yuav ua qhov sib sib zog nqus txiav rau hauv ib qho khoom, ces mus nrog ib qho kev sib txuas lus rau koj qhov kev txiav yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj. Tab sis yog tias koj xav tau qhov kev xaiv raug dua, ces qhov kev sib tw viav vias lossis oscillating motion yog qhov zoo tshaj plaws. Cov lus tsa suab kuj muaj kev cuam tshuam loj heev ntawm kev ceev.

Stoke Length & Ceev

Tus naj npawb ntawm strokes uas lub cuab yeej tuaj yeem ua thaum lub sijhawm txiav txiav txiav txim siab npaum li cas cov cuab yeej siv tau. Hauv cov ntsiab lus dav dav, qhov ntev stroke ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating yog qhov tsawg heev piv rau cov saw saws. Tab sis ntawm qhov tod tes, ib qho cuab yeej oscillating muaj qhov nrawm nrawm dua li qhov pom kev sib txuas. Tus txheej txheem oscillating cuab yeej muaj stroke ceev ntawm 20,000 strokes ib feeb. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, kev lag luam-theem reciprocating pom muaj stroke ceev ntawm 9,000 txog 10,000 stroker ib feeb. Yog li, tsis muaj kev xaiv zoo dua li cov cuab yeej oscillating rau kev ntxuav kom huv ntawm tus nqi nrawm dua.

Hniav Configuration ntawm cov cuab yeej

Cov hniav configuration ntawm ib tug oscillating saw yog heev nthuav, hais qhov tsawg tshaj plaws. Feem ntau cov cuab yeej oscillation yog square lossis duab plaub, tab sis ob peb muaj ib lub voj voog ib nrab ntawm lawv. Cov hniav ntawm cov hniav muaj nyob rau ntawm qhov kawg & ob sab ntawm cov hniav. Rau qhov kev xaiv semi-circular, cov hniav yog ib sab. Tam sim no, raws li peb txhua tus paub tias ntau hom hniav ntawm cov hniav oscillating muaj ntau lub hom phiaj, muaj cov hniav oscillating uas tsis muaj hniav. Ib qho piv txwv zoo ntawm cov hniav no yuav yog cov hniav siv rau cov xuab zeb nto nrog cov cuab yeej oscillating. Cov hniav siv rau polishing kuj muaj cov yam ntxwv zoo ib yam. Ntawm qhov tod tes, cov hniav configuration rau reciprocating hniav yog ib txwm zoo ib yam. Ib tug reciprocating hniav muaj nws cov hniav ntawm ib sab xwb. Lawv zoo li ultra-thin serrated riam. Cov hniav tuaj yeem hloov tau yog tias muaj kev hloov ntawm lub kaum sab xis ntawm qhov txiav. Raws li reciprocating saw siv nce thiab nqis, thaum koj ntxig cov hniav ntawm cov hniav, yuav tig ntsej muag los yog nqes nyob ntawm seb koj ntxig cov hniav ntawm lub saw.

Quality & Lifespan

Raws li reciprocating saws yog sturdier thiab robust piv rau oscillating cov cuab yeej, reciprocating saws muaj lifespan ntau dua oscillating cov cuab yeej. Qhov zoo ntawm cov corded version tseem zoo ib yam thaum lawv lub neej. Tab sis qhov zoo ntawm cordless version ntawm ob lub cuab yeej tau poob ntau xyoo. Nrog rau kev saib xyuas kom zoo, cov saw saw saw yuav kav ntev li ntawm 10 mus rau 15 xyoo, qhov twg cov cuab yeej oscillating yuav kav ntev li 5 xyoos nrog kev saib xyuas hnyav.

versatility

Qhov no yog qhov uas cov cuab yeej oscillating dominate dua reciprocating saws. Reciprocating saws yog siv rau ib lub hom phiaj nkaus xwb, thiab qhov ntawd yog pom lossis txiav los ntawm cov khoom. Tab sis cov cuab yeej oscillating tuaj yeem siv rau hauv ntau yam xwm txheej. Los ntawm kev txiav mus rau polishing thiab txawm sanding, oscillating cov cuab yeej muaj dominance tshaj yuav luag txhua cheeb tsam ntawm handyman thiab me me kev tsim kho tej hauj lwm.

Qhov Coob & Nyhav

Cov cuab yeej Oscillating yog qhov me me piv rau cov saw saws, lawv yog tsim rau kev txav mus los. Vim li ntawd, qhov loj thiab qhov hnyav ntawm qhov oscillating tsawg heev. Ntawm qhov tod tes, cov saw reciprocating yog qhov loj dua thiab yog ib qho ntawm cov cuab yeej hnyav tshaj plaws uas koj yuav ntsib hauv koj lub neej. Qhov laj thawj tseem ceeb rau qhov no yog qhov hnyav ntawm lub cev muaj zog nrog rau cov hniav thiab hlau lub cev ntawm cov saw.

durability

Qhov no tsis yog qhov tsis txaus ntseeg tias cov saw saw sib txuas yuav ua tau ntev dua li cov cuab yeej oscillation. Vim hais tias thaum qhov hnyav thiab qhov loj me tuaj yeem nyuaj rau kev nqa thiab sib npaug, nws kuj muab cov cuab yeej siv tau ntev thiab lub zog. Tias yog vim li cas thaum nws los txog rau durability, reciprocating pom yeej tshaj oscillating cov cuab yeej txhua zaus.

raug

Qhov no yog ib qho tseem ceeb ntawm cov cuab yeej xws li oscillating saw thiab reciprocating saw. Ib qho cuab yeej oscillating yog qhov zoo tshaj thaum nws los txog rau qhov tseeb thaum piv rau cov saw saws. Tias yog vim li cas qhov loj ntawm cov cuab yeej oscillating tsis loj heev rau koj los tswj, thiab nws tsis xa ntau lub zog raw. Yog li ntawd, nws yog qhov yooj yim heev los tuav thiab sib npaug. Ntawm qhov tod tes, lub hom phiaj tseem ceeb rau kev sib hloov saws yog rau kev rhuav tshem. Yog li ntawd, ib tug reciprocating saw tseem hu ua wrecker pom ntawm cov tub txawg. Nws qhov tseeb thiab qhov tseeb tsis yog qhov zoo tshaj plaws. Nws yog ib qho nyuaj heev los tswj, thiab koj yuav tsum tau siv koj lub cev tag nrho kom sib npaug ntawm cov saw sib txuas. Tab sis yog tias koj siv cov txheej txheem tsim nyog, ces koj tuaj yeem ua kom raug txiav txawm tias muaj cov saw saws.

Oscillating Tool vs Reciprocating Pom: Leej twg yog tus yeej?

Ob qho ntawm cov cuab yeej zoo heev ntawm qhov lawv ua. Nws nyob ntawm seb hom haujlwm twg koj yuav tsum tau ua tiav nrog cov cuab yeej. Yog tias koj tab tom ua haujlwm ntawm ib qho khoom me me lossis xav ua kom raug txiav tau yooj yim, ces cov cuab yeej oscillating yog tus yeej meej. Tab sis yog tias koj xav tau lub zog thiab xav txiav cov khoom muaj zog & loj dua, ces tsis muaj kev xaiv zoo dua li cov saw saws. Yog li, thaum kawg, txhua yam los ntawm hom phiaj xwm koj feem ntau cuam tshuam nrog.

xaus

Ob qho cuab yeej oscillating & reciprocating saws yog qhov zoo ntawm lawv ua. Yog li ntawd, tsis muaj tus yeej meej thaum nws los txog oscillating cuab tam vs reciprocating saw. Nws nyob ntawm qhov scenario heev. Thiab yog tias koj tau tuaj deb ntawm no hauv tsab xov xwm, ces koj twb paub nyob rau hauv cov xwm txheej twg cov cuab yeej ua tau zoo tshaj plaws. Yog li, siv qhov kev paub no los xaiv cov cuab yeej zoo tshaj plaws los ua koj txoj haujlwm yooj yim. Hmoov zoo!

Kuv yog Joost Nusselder, tus tsim ntawm Tools Doctor, cov ntsiab lus lag luam, thiab txiv. Kuv nyiam sim cov cuab yeej tshiab, thiab ua ke nrog kuv pab neeg kuv tau tsim cov ntawv blog tob txij li xyoo 2016 los pab cov neeg nyeem siab ncaj nrog cov cuab yeej & cov lus qhia ua khoom siv.