I-Dust Extractor vs Shop Vac: Iyiphi Emunca Kangcono? Thola Lapha!

nguJoost Nusselder | Kubuyekezwe ngomhla ka:  June 22, 2023
Ngiyakuthanda ukudala okuqukethwe kwamahhala okugcwele izeluleko zabafundi bami, wena. Angilwamukeli uxhaso olukhokhelwayo, umbono wami owami, kepha uma uthola izincomo zami zilusizo futhi ugcina uthenga okuthile okuthandayo ngesinye sezixhumanisi zami, bengingathola ikhomishini ngaphandle kwezindleko ezengeziwe kuwe. Funda kabanzi

Kukhona impikiswano enkulu mayelana nokuthi yiliphi ithuluzi elingcono lokuhlanza amapulangwe nama-sawdust. Abanye abantu bafunga ngesikhipha uthuli, kuyilapho abanye bekhetha i-vac yasesitolo.

Womabili amathuluzi asebenzisa ukumunca ukuze acoshe ukungcola nemfucumfucu, kodwa isikhiphi sothuli siklanyelwe ngokukhethekile ukususa izinhlayiya ezicolekile zothuli oluvela emoyeni kuyilapho umshini wokuvala isitolo ukufanelekela ukucosha udoti omkhulu njengamapulangwe namasaha phansi.

Kulesi sihloko, ngizongena phakathi komehluko phakathi kwala mathuluzi futhi ngikusize unqume ukuthi yiliphi elikulungele.

I-Dust extractor vs i-shop vac

Thenga I-Vac vs Iqoqo Lothuli: Iyiphi Okufanele Uyikhethe?

Uma kuziwa ekuhlanzeni indawo yakho yokusebenza, uzodinga ithuluzi elingasusa kahle izinhlayiya nothuli. Nakuba kokubili ama-vacs esitolo kanye neziqoqi zothuli zenzelwe le njongo, kunomehluko obalulekile phakathi kwakho kokubili.

I-shop vac iyithuluzi eliphathekayo nelinamandla elisebenzisa ukumunca ukucosha udoti omncane nothuli. Ilungele ukuhlanzwa okusheshayo futhi ingasetshenziselwa imisebenzi eyahlukene, kusukela ekuhlanzeni itafula lakho lomsebenzi kuya ekucosheni uthuli olusaha phansi. Ngakolunye uhlangothi, a umqoqi wothuli (ongcono kakhulu lapha) iyiyunithi ezinikele eklanyelwe ukususa izinhlayiya ezinhle emoyeni. Ivamise ukusetshenziswa ezindaweni ezinkudlwana, njengesitudiyo noma indawo yokusebenzela, futhi iphumelela kakhulu ekucupheni uthuli ngaphambi kokuthi ihlale endaweni.

Izinto Okufanele Zicatshangelwe Lapho Ukhetha Phakathi Kwevac Yesitolo Nokuqoqwa Kwezintuli

Ngaphambi kokunquma ukuthi yiliphi ithuluzi ongalithenga, kunezici ezimbalwa okufanele uzicabangele:

  • Usayizi wendawo yakho yokusebenzela: Uma unendawo yokusebenzela encane, indawo yokusebenzela yesitolo ingaba inketho engcono kakhulu njengoba iminyene futhi kulula ukuyigcina. Kodwa-ke, uma unendawo enkulu, umuntu oqoqa uthuli angase adingeke ukuze aqinisekise ukuthi umoya uhlanzekile futhi uhlanzekile.
  • Uhlobo lomsebenzi wakho: Uma usebenza ngokhuni noma ezinye izinto ezikhiqiza uthuli oluningi, umqoqi wothuli kufanele ube nakho. Kodwa-ke, uma udinga kuphela ukuhlanza ukungcola okuncane, i-vac yesitolo ingase yanele.
  • Izinga lokuhlunga elidingekayo: Abaqoqi bothuli ngokuvamile banezigaba eziningi zokuhlunga, okusho ukuthi bangasusa ngisho nezinhlayiya ezinhle kakhulu emoyeni. Ngakolunye uhlangothi, ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile anesefa esisodwa esingase singasebenzi kahle ekubambeni uthuli olucolekile.
  • Amandla adingekayo: Uma udinga ithuluzi elingakwazi ukuhlanza umsebenzi osindayo, umqoqi wothuli uyindlela okufanele uhambe ngayo. Kodwa-ke, uma udinga kuphela ithuluzi ozolisebenzisa ngezikhathi ezithile, i-vac yesitolo ingaba yinketho engcono.

Izinzuzo Zokusebenzisa Isiqoqi Sothuli

Ngenkathi i-shop vac iyithuluzi elihle lokuhlanza ngokushesha, umqoqi wothuli unezinzuzo ezimbalwa ezikwenza kube ukukhetha okungcono ezimweni ezithile:

  • Isebenza kahle kakhulu ekukhipheni izinhlayiya ezinhle: Iziqoqi zothuli zenzelwe ukususa ngisho nezinhlayiya ezincane kakhulu emoyeni, okubalulekile uma usebenza ngezinto ezikhiqiza uthuli oluningi.
  • Ukulawula okungcono ukugeleza komoya: Abaqoqi bothuli ngokuvamile banefeni engalungiswa ukuze kulawulwe ukugeleza komoya. Lokhu kubalulekile uma udinga ukudala izinga elithile lokugeleza komoya endaweni yakho yokusebenza.
  • Izigaba eziningi zokuhlunga: Abaqoqi bothuli ngokuvamile banezigaba eziningi zokuhlunga, okusho ukuthi bangasusa izinhlayiya eziningi emoyeni kune-vac yesitolo.

Kokubili izinto ezikhipha uthuli kanye nemishini yokuvala izitolo zidlala indima ebalulekile ekugcineni indawo yokusebenza ihlanzekile. Nazi ezinye izici ezibenza babe ngamathuluzi abalulekile:

  • Ama-dust extractors ahamba phambili ekubambeni nasekususeni izinhlayiya ezihamba emoyeni, okuzenza zibe zilungele izinhlelo zokusebenza zezimboni nezamapulangwe.
  • Ama-vacs esitolo anikezela ngezinto ezihlukahlukene ekuphatheni imfucumfucu emanzi neyomile, iyenza ibe wusizo ngezinjongo zokuhlala noma ze-DIY.
  • Izihlungi zothuli zinezihlungi ezingcono, ngokuvamile ibanga le-HEPA, ezivalela izinhlayiya zehle zifike ku-0.3 microns, okuqinisekisa ukuthi umoya ozungezile uhlanzekile.
  • Ama-vac esitolo anamandla ahlukene okuhlunga, okuwenza akwazi ukuphatha ukungcola okuhlukahlukene.
  • Izinto ezikhipha uthuli ziyaphatheka futhi zingayiswa endaweni yomsebenzi, kuyilapho ama-vacs esitolo esetshenziswa kakhulu endaweni yokusebenzela noma egalaji.

Kuyini Ukusebenzelana Nabaqoqi Uthuli?

Ngenkathi umshini wokuvala isitolo uklanyelwe ukucosha udoti phansi, isikhipha uthuli siklanyelwe ukuqoqa uthuli nezinye izinhlayiya emoyeni. Umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-dust extractor kanye ne-vac yesitolo yile:

  • Ivolumu: Izikhiqizo zothuli zingahambisa umthamo womoya omkhulu kunezikhala zasesitolo, zizenze zisebenze kahle ekuthwebuleni izinhlayiya ezihamba emoyeni.
  • Ukuhlunga: Izihlungi zothuli zinezihlungi ezingcono, ngokuvamile ibanga le-HEPA, ezingavalela uthuli oluphuma emoyeni lwehle lufike kuma-microns angu-0.3.
  • Izikhwama: Izikhiqizi zothuli zisebenzisa izikhwama ukuqoqa uthuli, kuyilapho ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile esebenzisa i-canister noma isihlungi.
  • Ukuphatheka: Izikhiqizo zothuli zenzelwe ukuthi zithwaleke futhi zingayiswa ezindaweni zokusebenza, kuyilapho ama-vacs ezitolo ngokuvamile amile.

Asebenza Kanjani Ama-Dust Collectors?

Abaqoqi bothuli basebenza ngokusebenzisa isisefo ukuze bathwebule futhi basuse uthuli nezinye izinhlayiya ezisemoyeni. Umoya udonselwa kumqoqi wothuli ngepayipi noma ipayipi, bese udlula ngesihlungi. Isihlungi sithwebula uthuli nezinye izinhlayiya, kuyilapho umoya ohlanzekile udedelwa ubuyele endaweni ezungezile. Uthuli luqoqwa esikhwameni noma ku-canister, engase ichithwe noma ishintshwe njengoba kudingeka.

Thenga I-Vac: Ithuluzi Elisebenzayo Elingakwenza Konke

I-vac yesitolo wuhlobo lwe I vacuum cleaner eklanyelwe ukucosha izinhlayiya nemfucumfucu ezindaweni zokwakha, izindawo zokusebenzela, nakwezinye izindawo lapho ama-vacuum avamile angaba nzima khona ukuwahlanza. Kuyithuluzi elinamandla elikwaziyo ukuphatha ukungcola okumanzi nokomile, okulenza libe ukungezwa okuguquguqukayo kunoma iyiphi indawo yokusebenza. Ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile mancane futhi ayaphatheka kakhulu kunezikhiqizi zothuli ezizinikele, okuwenza abe iyunithi ewusizo yokuba nawo ngqo.

Uyini Umehluko phakathi kweVac yasesitolo kanye Nesikhipha Uthuli?

Nakuba kokubili ama-vacs esitolo kanye nezikhipha uthuli kuklanyelwe ukucosha uthuli nemfucumfucu, kunomehluko obalulekile phakathi kwakho kokubili. Ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile aguquguqukayo futhi ayakwazi ukuphatha ukuhlukahluka okukhulu, kuyilapho izinto ezikhipha uthuli zigxile enqubweni yokuqoqwa kothuli. Izikhiqizo zothuli ziklanyelwe ukubamba amanani amakhulu othuli nemfucumfucu, okuzenza zibe ukukhetha okungcono kwemisebenzi emikhulu. Kodwa-ke, ama-vacs esitolo alungele ukuhlanzwa okusheshayo nemisebenzi emincane.

Yiziphi izici zeVac yasesitolo?

  • Ama-vacs esitolo aziwa ngamandla awo aphezulu kanye nekhono lokumunca, okuwenza abe yinketho edumile yokuhlanza umsebenzi osindayo.
  • Afika ngezinhlobo namamodeli ahlukene, amanye akhelwe ngokuqondile ukungcola okumanzi, kanti amanye afaneleka kangcono ukungcola okomile.
  • Ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile anenani eliphansi uma kuqhathaniswa nezikhipha uthuli, okuwenza abe inketho efinyeleleka kalula kulabo abasebhajethi.
  • Futhi ziguquguquka kakhulu kunezikhipha uthuli, zinekhono lokucosha uhla olubanzi lwemfucumfucu, okuhlanganisa amanzi nezinhlayiya ezinkulu.
  • Ama-vacs esitolo aklanyelwe ukuthi abe usizo futhi kulula ukuhambahamba, anezici ezifana namasondo nezibambo ukuze kube lula ukuwahambisa.
  • Amanye amamodeli we-vac esitolo nawo eza nezici ezengeziwe ezifana namapayipi akhiphekayo, izihlungi, nama-nozzles, okuwenza asebenziseke nakakhulu emisebenzini ehlukene yokuhlanza.

Kungani Kufanele Ucabange Ukuthenga I-Vac Yesitolo?

  • Ama-vacs esitolo ayithuluzi eliwusizo ongaba nalo kunoma iyiphi indawo yokusebenza, okwenza kube lula ukugcina indawo ihlanzekile futhi ingenalo uthuli nemfucumfucu.
  • Bayakwazi ukusingatha izinhlobonhlobo zezinxushunxushu, kusukela ekushicileleni ngokhuni ukuya ekuchithekeni kwamanzi, okubenza babe isengezo esiguquguqukayo kunoma yikuphi. ibhokisi lamathuluzi (hlola le mikhiqizo).
  • Ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile athengeka kakhulu kunezikhipha uthuli, okuwenza abe inketho enhle kulabo abasebenzisa isabelomali.
  • Ziyakwazi futhi ukuphatheka kalula futhi kulula ukuhambahamba, okwenza kube ukukhetha okulula kulabo abadinga ukuhlanza izindawo ezahlukene njalo.

Yini Ongayibheka Lapho Ukhetha I-Vac Yesitolo?

  • Hlola amandla nekhono lokumunca le-vac yesitolo ukuze uqinisekise ukuthi iqine ngokwanele ngokwezidingo zakho.
  • Cabangela ubukhulu nesisindo se-vac yesitolo, njengoba amamodeli asindayo angaba nzima ukuhambahamba.
  • Bheka izici ezengeziwe njengamapayipi akhiphekayo nezihlungi ukuze wenze ukuhlanza kube lula.
  • Nquma ukuthi uyawudinga yini umshini wokuvala isitolo oklanyelwe ngokuqondile ukungcola okumanzi noma ukungcola okomile, noma leyo ekwazi ukubhekana nakho kokubili.
  • Cabangela umkhiqizo futhi ufunde izibuyekezo ukuze uthole i-vac yesitolo engcono kakhulu yezidingo zakho.

Impi Yamandla Okumunca: Yikuphi Okuphezulu, Isikhiqizi Sothuli noma I-Shop Vac?

Amandla okumunca amandla adonsa uthuli nemfucumfucu ku-vacuum. Yisici esibaluleke kakhulu ekunqumeni ukusebenza kahle kwesikhipha uthuli noma i-vac yesitolo. Lapho amandla okumunca ephakama, yilapho i-vacuum iphumelela kakhulu ekucosheni uthuli nemfucumfucu.

Yikuphi Okufanele Ukhethe?

Ukukhetha phakathi kwe-dust extractor kanye ne-vac yesitolo ekugcineni kuncike ezidingweni zakho. Uma usebenza kuphrojekthi enkulu ekhiqiza uthuli oluningi nemfucumfucu, isikhipha uthuli siyindlela okufanele uhambe ngayo. Kodwa-ke, uma usebenza kumaphrojekthi amancane noma udinga i-vacuum ephathekayo, i-vac yesitolo iyona ndlela engcono kakhulu.

Ulwazi Lwami Lomuntu Siqu

Njengomkhandi wezinkuni, ngisebenzise kokubili okokukhipha uthuli kanye namavaki esitolo esitolo sami. Nakuba ngithanda amandla okumunca okokukhipha uthuli kumaphrojekthi amakhulu, ngithola ukuthi i-vac yesitolo ilungele imisebenzi emincane. Ekugcineni, kuncike kulokho okuthandayo kanye nezidingo ezithile zephrojekthi yakho.

Ukuhlunga Uthuli: Ukuthuthukisa Amakhono Okukhipha Uthuli Lwakho noma i-Shop Vac

Uma kukhulunywa ngokukhipha uthuli, amandla okuhlunga abalulekile. Umsebenzi oyinhloko wesikhipha uthuli noma i-vac yesitolo ukubamba futhi iqukathe uthuli nemfucumfucu, ivimbele ukuthi ingaphinde ijikeleze emoyeni. Ikhwalithi yesihlungi esisetshenziswe enqubeni yiyona enquma ukusebenza kahle kwesistimu.

Idizayini Yesihlungi Esithuthukile

Izihlungi zothuli kanye nama-vac esitolo ngokuvamile afakwe izihlungi eziyisisekelo ezihlanganisa izinto ezinamaphiko noma ezinegwebu. Nokho, ngamakhono okuhlunga aphakeme, imiklamo yokuhlunga emisha isiyatholakala. Lezi zihlungi zenzelwe ngokukhethekile ukuthwebula ngisho nezinhlayiyana ezincane kakhulu, kuqinisekiswe ukuthi umoya uhlanzekile futhi uphephe kakhudlwana ukuze uphefumule.

I-Cyclonic Separators

Ukufaka izihlukanisi ze-cyclonic ohlelweni lwakho lokukhipha uthuli kuthuthukisa kakhulu amandla ayo. Lezi zihlukanisi zisebenzisa amandla aphakathi nendawo ukuze zihlukanise izinhlayiya ezinkulu nezisindayo emoyeni ongenayo, zinciphise umsebenzi wesihlungi futhi zandise isikhathi saso sokuphila. I-spin edalwe yisihlukanisi se-cyclonic ibangela ukuthi udoti uphonswe ngaphandle, ukuvimbele ukuthi ungavali isihlungi futhi uvumele amandla angaphazamiseki okumunca.

Inhlanganisela Systems

Ukuhlanganisa izihlukanisi ze-cyclonic nezihlungi ezithuthukisiwe kuthuthukisa kakhulu ukusebenza kahle okuphelele kwesikhiphi sakho sothuli noma i-vac yesitolo. Lezi zinhlelo zenzelwe ukubamba ngisho nezinhlayiya ezincane kakhulu ezihamba emoyeni, zizivimbele ukuthi zingaphinde zijikeleze futhi zigcine indawo yokusebenza ihlanzekile.

Ukunakekela Kwenziwe Kwalula

Ukusebenzisa amandla okuhluza okuthuthukile akuthuthukisi nje kuphela ikhwalithi yomoya owuphefumulayo, kodwa kwenza nokugcinwa kube lula. Ngokuthatha nokuhlukanisa imfucumfucu eqoqiwe, isihlungi mancane amathuba okuthi sivaleke, sinciphise isidingo sokuhlanza njalo. Lokhu konga isikhathi nomzamo, kukuvumela ukuthi ugxile emsebenzini wakho.

Ohambweni: Ukufaneleka Kokuphatheka Nokusebenza

Uma kuziwa ekukhetheni phakathi kwe-dust extractor kanye ne-vac yesitolo, enye yezinto ezibalulekile okufanele icatshangelwe ukuphatheka nokuhamba kahle. Nakuba womabili amathuluzi enzelwe ukugcina indawo yakho yokusebenza ihlanzekile futhi ingenalo uthuli nemfucumfucu, ayahluka ngokuya ngokuhamba kwawo.

Isikhiphi sothuli sivamise ukuba sikhulu futhi simile, siklanyelwe ukufakwa unomphela endaweni yokusebenzela noma igaraji. Ngakolunye uhlangothi, i-vac yesitolo incane futhi iyaphatheka, okuyenza ifaneleke ukusetshenziswa ezilungiselelweni ezihlukahlukene.

I-Mobile Factor: Izinzuzo ze-Shop Vac

Uma ungumuntu odinga ukunyakazisa ithuluzi lakho lokuhlanza njalo, i-vac yesitolo ingaba yinketho engcono kuwe. Nazi ezinye izinzuzo zokusebenzisa i-vac yesitolo:

  • Ayisindi futhi kulula ukuhambahamba: Ama-vacs esitolo ngokuvamile mancane futhi alula kunezikhipha uthuli, okwenza kube lula ukuhambahamba endaweni yakho yokusebenza.
  • Okuphathekayo: Imishini eminingi yezitolo iza namasondo noma isibambo, okwenza kube lula ukuyihambisa isuka kwenye indawo iye kwenye.
  • Okuguquguqukayo: Izikhala zesitolo zingasetshenziselwa imisebenzi eyahlukene yokuhlanza, kusukela ekuhlanzeni ama-sawdust endaweni yokusebenzela ukuya ekuhlanzeni imoto yakho.
  • Kuyathengeka: Izikhala zesitolo ngokuvamile zingabizi kakhulu kunezikhipha uthuli, okuzenza zibe ukukhetha okuhle kulabo abasebenzisa isabelomali.

Izikhiqizi Zothuli: Lapho Ukuphatheka Kungekona Okubalulekile

Yize isikhiphi sothuli singase singahambi njenge-vac yesitolo, sinezinzuzo ezithile ngokwaso. Nazi ezinye izizathu zokuthi kungani ungakhetha i-dust extractor:

  • Kunamandla kakhulu: Izikhiqizo zothuli ngokuvamile zinamandla kakhulu kunezikhala zasesitolo, zizenza zifaneleke kangcono imisebenzi yokuhlanza umsebenzi osindayo.
  • Ukuhlunga okungcono: Izinto ezikhipha uthuli zivame ukuba nezinhlelo zokuhlunga ezingcono kunezikhala zasesitolo, ezingabaluleka uma usebenza ngezinto eziyingozi.
  • Okuzolile: Izinto ezikhipha uthuli ngokuvamile zithule kunezikhala zasesitolo, okungase kucatshangelwe uma usebenza endaweni okwabelwana ngayo.

Isiphetho

Ngakho, iyiphi okufanele uyithole? 

Kuya ngezidingo zakho kanye nohlobo lomsebenzi owenzayo. Uma ufuna ithuluzi lokuhlanza ukungcola okuncane, i-vac yesitolo iyindlela okufanele uhambe ngayo. Kodwa uma ufuna ithuluzi lokuhlanza izindawo ezinkulu, i-dust extractor iyithuluzi lakho. 

Ngakho-ke, ungamane uthenge isicoci sevacuum ngaphandle kokucabanga ngezidingo zakho kanye nohlobo lomsebenzi owenzayo.

Ngingu-Joost Nusselder, umsunguli we-Tools Doctor, umakethi wokuqukethwe, kanye nobaba. Ngiyakuthanda ukuzama okokusebenza okusha, futhi kanye nethimba lami ngidale izindatshana zebhulogi ezijulile kusukela ngo-2016 ukuze ngisize abafundi abathembekile ngamathuluzi namathiphu okwenza.